Cottage Rentals Finger Lakes NY
26 properties available
Enjoy your family vacation at Keuka Pines Compound! These 3 cottages consist of 6 bedrooms, 2 lofts and 4 bathrooms. A walkout lakeview covered porch completes this quaint setup. Rent Keuka Pines Main, Keuka Pines Bungalow B and Keuka Pines Bungalow C together to rent Keuka Pines Compound. Please call the office to inquire about availability, or vi
This original and beautifully maintained lake cottage is the ideal vacation home, with some recent updates and remodeling for a modern flair, but keeping with the nostalgic feel of an original lake residence. Located off the main road, this charming cottage has many features that make it an appealing location for your next family vacation. Ent
Looking for a woodland log cabin retreat, but not looking to sacrifice luxury? The Cedar Lodge offers warm, rustic charm and the feeling of a secluded hide-away without compromising any of the comforts that make a house feel like home. Add to that access to some of the most beautiful lakefront and views in the Finger Lakes, and this lakeside house
You’ll be quick to see just how “Off the Hook” this home is when you’re wanting to plan your next Finger Lakes vacation before you even leave! With 100’ of Conesus lakefront and gorgeous sunset views, this lake home is the perfect setting for your friends and family alike. Plan your stay with day trips to n
Babe-A-Lew is a grand setting for the family get-away that’s looking for outdoor living. Families large and small or couples travelling together can enjoy this spacious home, large front porch and extensive lakefront. Plenty of parking and walk-in access through the rear of the house makes unpacking the cars a breeze.Enter the rear of the hou
One of the most cozy and convenient cottages on Keuka's east side!You can enter the home from the first or second floor. First floor features an updated kitchen, spacious living room, a dining nook overlooking the lakefront, and a screen porch for dining or enjoying the view. Two bedrooms are located on the first floor as well as a full bathroo
Renovations for Keuka Pines Main House are fully underway! With renovations due to be complete in Spring of 2024, guests are able to expect a larger kitchen with new cabinetry, fixtures and appliances (including a dishwasher!). A wrap around deck will span the length of the kitchen area around to the lake side of the upper level balcony
Nestled in the hillside and surrounded by trees midway between Hammondsport and Penn Yan; The Ironwood is the perfect home for classic Keuka Lake travelers. This traditional lake home is located on a quiet, residential road where neighbors are friendly and where your Finger Lakes getaway will be one to remember. Situated across the road
This Keuka Lake classic, 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage features one of the best views on Keuka Lake and is located directly below a scenic overlook. Wakiva Esperanza sits on a quiet, dead-end road within a short walk to Keuka Lake State Park and its many trails.For the nature lover, trees surround the cottage and offer shade on those hot summer d
With a name that says it all; Knotty and Nice is a rare Finger Lakes classic on the east side of Seneca Lake. North of Watkins Glen, this home is perfect for your friends and family alike whether you’re attending an event at the track, or you’ve got a wine or beer tour planned. The main entry offers a cozy living area to gree
Located minutes from award-winning wineries along the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, this is the perfect location to explore Finger Lakes wine country with friends and family.Lucky Stone Cottage is a lovely 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath ranch-style lake house set on 5 quiet acres, with 150 feet of private lakefront along the western shore of Cayuga Lake.Guests can
This charming, two-story lakeside cottage is located on the West Bluff of beautiful Keuka Lake. Bluestone Cottage offers beautiful sunsets and fantastic lake views for your enjoyment and relaxation.As you walk down to the first landing, you will enter the second level where all the bedrooms and full bath are located. The first bedroom is painted li
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.